Benebone vs. Nylabone: Which Dog Chew Is Better For Your Dog?

Anna Mejorada By
Anna Mejorada
Anna Mejorada
Anna Mejorada
Anna Mejorada is a commerce writer for The Spruce Pets.
Learn more about The Spruce Pets' Editorial Process
Published on 08/16/23

We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.Learn more.

Benebone-bacon-flavor-wishbone-tough-dog-chew-toy

Amazon

Giving your dog a durable dog chew will keep them entertained for hours, ease anxiety, and help them expend energy in a healthy way (instead of destroying your furniture, for example). They can even reduce build-up on doggy teeth. Benebone and Nylabone are among the most popular manufacturers of these durable chew toys, and each offer a variety of chews for dogs of all ages and sizes. They're a fantastic alternative to bones, antlers, and other chews that areno longer recommended for dogs.

To help you find the right dog chew for your dog, we compared popular options from each brand: the Power Chew from Nylabone and the Wishbone from Benebone. We think both chew toys are fantastic options for most dogs—both the Power Chew and the Wishbone star inour roundup of the best dog toys for tough chewers. But while both have their distinct advantages, ultimately we settled on a winner, that we think is the better pick in most circumstances.

Our Winner

Benebone Wishbone

While both Benebone Wishbone and Nylabone Power Chew are made out of nylon, which should not be ingested, Benebone uses real ingredients to add flavors dogs love, including peanuts, chicken, pork, fish, beef, and maple wood—all of which are sourced and manufactured in the United States. In addition to the Wishbone, Benebone offers six other styles of dog chews: Dental Chew, Fishbone, Tripe Bone, Zaggler, Stick, and Pawplexer. And within those shapes, Benebone offers chews to meet the needs of puppies with growing teeth, dogs under 15 pounds, and dogs as large as 120 pounds.

Versus Highlights

Nylabone Benebone
Four types: Puppy Chew, Flexi Chew, Strong Chew, Power Chew Seven types: Wishbone, Dental Chew, Fishbone, Tripe Bone, Zaggler, Stick, and Pawplexer
Three flavors: Peanut Butter, Chicken, Bacon Six flavors: Bacon, Peanut Butter, Chicken, Jack Salmon, Maple Wood, Beef Tripe
Five sizes: Petite (up to 15 pounds), Regular (16-25 pounds), Wolf (26-35 pounds), Giant (36-49 pounds), Souper (50+ pounds) Flavored using real peanuts, chicken, pork, fish, beef, and maple wood
Manufactured in the United States Five sizes: Tiny (up to 15 pounds), Small (16-30 pounds), Medium (31-60 pounds), Large (61-90 pounds, Giant (91-120 pounds)
Ingredients sourced and products manufactured in the United States
Recycling program,TerraCycle, offered for used Benebone dog chews
Our Top Picks
Nylabone Power Chew Original Flavored Dog Chew Toy at Chewy
Jump to Review
Benebone Bacon Flavor Wishbone at Chewy
Jump to Review

Nylabone Power Chew Original Flavored Dog Chew Toy

Nylabone Power Chew Original Flavored Dog Chew Toy

Chewy
View On Chewy View On HorseloverZ.com View On Ace Hardware

Who It’s For:For guardians of any dog looking for a tough chew toy, but we especially like Nylabone for big dogs. The Nylabone Power Chew Durable Dog Toy isour top-tested choiceafter successfully spending two weeks in a home with a destructive pit bull. The x-large size (for dogs 50+ pounds) is called the Souper because it resembles the look of a soup bone. The chewer is primarily intended for use in a horizontal position with a dog using their front paws to stabilize, but can also be used for quick games of fetch and tug-of-war.

Price at time of publish:$7 (regular, 16-25 pounds)

Ingredients:Flavored nylon |Flavors:Original (chicken), bacon, peanut butter |大小s:Puppies, petite (up to 15 pounds), regular (16-25 pounds), wolf (26-35 pounds), giant (36-49 pounds), souper (50+ pounds)

Benebone Bacon Flavor Wishbone Tough Dog Chew Toy

4.2
Benebone-bacon-flavor-wishbone-tough-dog-chew-toy

Amazon
View On Chewy View On Amazon View On PETCO

Who It’s For:For any dog parent in search of a solution to their dog’s chewing habit. Butafter testing 25 dog chewers, we strongly recommend the Benebone Wishbone for those with smaller dogs in their homes. The Benebone Wishbone dog chewer comes in two sizes for little ones, Tiny, for dogs under 15 pounds, and Small, for dogs 16 to 30 pounds. Plus, the wishbone-shaped dog chews are dense, but not heavy. Plus, the two-pronged design is intended to be more ergonomic in addition to offering more surface space.

Price at time of publish:$12 (small, 16-30 pounds)

Ingredients:Flavored nylon |Flavors:Bacon, peanut butter, chicken |大小s:Puppies, tiny (up to 15 pounds), small (16-30 pounds), medium (31-60 pounds), large (61-90 pounds), giant (91-120 pounds)

Benebone vs. Nylabone Results

Effectiveness

Winner:Tie

两个狗咬是由耐用的尼龙United States–Benebone in New York and Nylabone in New Jersey–and will engage a canine through the enticing appeal of flavor. The duration of chomping entertainment your dog experiences will vary depending on your dog’s strength and determination.

大小

Winner:Benebone

While both offer five sizes for adult dogs–along with puppy-specific versions of their chews–Benebone’s option covers a larger range, from Tiny (up to 15 pounds) to Giant (91-120 pounds). Whereas, Nylabone caps its size range at 50+ pounds.

Value

Winner:Nylabone

Both are durable, but within the same size bracket, Nylabone is available at a lower price point. Depending on how often you need to replace the dog chew, opting for a Nylabone might be more aligned with your budget.

Flavor

Winner:Benebone

While Nylabone and Benebone both seem to appeal to a dog’s sense of smell and taste, Benebone is the winner here because they always use real ingredients sourced in the United States to flavor their nylon dog chew, including peanuts, chicken, pork, fish, beef, and maple wood. But if someone in your home has a severe food allergy, then bringing any Benebone product into your space is not recommended.

Shape

Winner:Benebone

The wishbone shape of Benebone provides more angles and flavored surfaces to keep a dog engaged. The Nylabone shape does change as it gets larger, but all variations of the dog chew are based on the standard dog bone shape.

Why trust The Spruce Pets

This story was written byAnna Mejorada, a writer for The Spruce Pets, who shares her home with a happy Pomeranian named Gidget. Before researching and writing about pet products for a living, Mejorada embarked on a self-mandated, ongoing quest to find the optimal items for her dog. She is now delightfully devoted to helping humans discover and select the most favorable products for their pets.